Generative patterns: Ideal, Obstacles, Outcomes (IdOO)
IdOO (“I do”) – a mnemonic for Ideal, Obstacles, Outcomes – is one of two key generative patterns in Agendashift. We use the IdOO pattern at different times and with different combinations of tools and prompts, but still the underlying pattern easily recognised.
Authentic agreement on meaningful outcomes is the most powerful enabler for strategic change that we know. IdOO promotes this by:
- Having outcomes identified and articulated through participation in a generative process, not imposed from outside
- Ensuring by construction that they are connected to needs
Specific instances of the pattern
- In Discovery, reflecting on our provided True North statement, in a business context established by preceding exercises (Celebration-5W in particular), and the resulting outcomes organised in a Plan on a Page
- In Exploration, reflecting on prompts prioritised from our 42-prompt assessment, context already established in Discovery, and outcomes then organised through Mapping
Our various outside-in strategy review workshops employ the IdOO pattern either once or twice (see the OI-SR template for detail on the ‘layers’ below):
- In the Impact! workshop, for the Customer layer (only)
- In the Wholehearted:OKR workshop, initially for the Customer and Organisation layers and later the Product, Platform, and Teams(s) layers
For both kinds of strategy workshop, the IdOO pattern is often there (though less explictly) in the ideation process, starting this time with the Ideal foe a specific outcome.
Demonstrating IdOO at its most simple, the Agendashift True North deck asks the questions below in sequence, one slide at a time (the True North statement fulfulling the role of generative image, evoking a wide range of possible responses both spoken and unspoken):
- When this is working at its ideal best for us, what’s that like?
- And when that's happening, what new stories could we tell?
- And in those stories, whose needs would we be meeting?
- What stops that? What gets in the way?
- What would you like to have happen?
- Then what happens? (And perhaps again: Then what happens?)
Ideal: This is the result of the reflection (written down or otherwise) and should not be confused with the generative image, challenge, or other prompt – provided or harvested – used by the facilitator in the reflection’s setup.
Obstacles: Their elicitation is usually straightforward – from experience we have learned to use neutral but direct questioning – often as simple as “What stops that?”. In certain circumstances however it may be appropriate to employ a more elaborate obstacle identification exercise. Regardless of they are generated, it’s important afterwards to check that obstacles identify real issues and don’t suffer from certain unhelpful framings (see Good Obstacle, Bad Obstacle).
Outcomes: These can be generated by various means, for example one of the two variants of our Clean Language-inspired coaching game, 15-minute FOTO, the miracle question (Solution Focus, see below), or some combination. As already indicated, outcomes can be organised in multiple ways after generation.
IdOO is not always linear. For example, although 15-minute FOTO is mainly about exploring and developing a landscape of outcomes, further obstacles may be identified in that process, and from those, more outcomes. It could be said therefore that the process builds a fractal landscape of both obstacles and outcomes. And at any point, a new ideal can be established and the process started afresh.
The strategy 'wrapper'
Two patterns for the price of one! For best results:
- Establish context – see for example Celebration-5W
- Have the conversation(s) – IdOO-based or otherwise
- Organise the strategy – Mapping, OKR, etc, avoiding the temptation to stop at 'next steps' and losing most of what was discussed.
The classic coaching model GROW (en.wikipedia.org) – Goal, Reality, Options, Way forward. Because we are developing strategy, IdOO departs from that highly recommended model in two key respects:
- We seek to generate a landscape of outcomes – potentially a fractal landscape with further obstacles and their corresponding outcomes embedded within it – covering a range of timescales
- Rather than seeking to help the client towards their next actionable step, we go on to organise outcomes to reveal lines of sight between near-term opportunities, key results, medium-term objectives, and long-term goals; by their construction we can reasonably expect to find coherence here
From the Clean Language community, to which the Agendashift community is closely aligned, the PRO model – Problem, Remedy, Outcome (cleanlanguage.co.uk) – by Penny Tompkins and James Lawley. The ability to recognise the differences between the three elements of the model and to move conversations between them are certainly valuable skills. Comparing PRO and IdOO:
- Problem and obstacle are similar, differing perhaps more in tone than in substance
- In IdOO, not seeking remedies at this stage, we are happy to gloss over them, replacing them with their respective outcomes (a strategy applicable in Clean Language coaching also). In Agendashift, potential solutions are considered later in the process, often loosely held as hypotheses and experiments. See Agendashift’s other key pattern, Right-to-Left Strategy Deployment.
- Outcomes in the two models are the same.
The miracle question (Solution Focus): See en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solution-focused_brief_therapy#The_miracle_question and The Solution Focus, Paul Z. Jackson & Mark McKergow (Nicholas Brealey International, 2011)
Further to the above, Practice Outcomes, aka 5% Outcomes, 15% Outcomes (blog.agendashift.com), an optional warmup to 15-minute FOTO
Challenge Mapping (Sid Parnes, Min Basadur) – broadening and narrowing with Why and What, responses captured in How might we...? (HMW) form:
- “Why [is this an important challenge]?”, “Why else?”, and contextualised forms such as Why is solving this important?, Why is achieving this important?
- “What’s stopping us?”, “What else?”, etc
- Reducing Complexity in Conceptual Thinking Using Challenge Mapping
Min Basadur (researchgate.net, 2003)
- Challenge Mapping – a powerful method for finding the right focus
Piritta Kantojärvi (grapepeople.fi, 2017)
- Challenge Mapping Part 1 - Challenge Map Basics
Jeanine Harriman (7leaguestudio.com, 2019)
- Reappreciating: “How Might We?”
GK VanPatter (linkedin.com, 2015)
From the Lean community (to which we also align), some resonances with Mike Rother’s Toyota Kata have been noted. Like the katas, IdOO could be described as a ‘routine’ to be practiced.
- Agendashift: Outcome-oriented change and continuous transformation , Mike Burrows (2nd edition 2021)
- Right to Left: The digital leader’s guide to Lean and Agile, Mike Burrows (2019, audiobook 2020)
Agendashift™ is copyright © 2015-2022 Positive Incline Ltd. All rights reserved. The page Ideal, Obstacles, Outcomes (IdOO) by Mike Burrows of Positive Incline Ltd is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/.
Source text maintained at github.com/asplake/agendashift-open/tree/master/framework/patterns/idoo.md (github.com)
For image source files (or simply to join the Agendashift mailing list), just ask:
I understand that I will be joining the Agendashift mailing list also
- Agendashift as framework
- Agendashift's five core activities
- Models, sources, and inspirations
- Agendashift: Outcome-oriented change and continuous transformation (2nd edition 2021)
- Right to Left: The digital leader’s guide to Lean and Agile (2019, audiobook 2020)
Meet us online
Agendashift™ is brought to you by Positive Incline Ltd, UK-based specialists in Lean, Agile, strategy, and change. Founder Mike Burrows came to prominence in the Lean-Agile community as the orginator of Kanban’s values model, out of which came his first book, Kanban from the Inside (2014). His more recent books Agendashift (2nd edition 2021) and Right to Left (2019, audiobook 2020) bring a resolutely needs-based and outcome-oriented perspective to change, transformation, and the Lean-Agile landscape as a whole, contributing meanwhile a number of popular tools, games, and other resources. He works as a consultant, facilitator, and trainer, and as a keynote speaker at events public and private around the world.
Agendashift™ is copyright © 2015-2022 Positive Incline Ltd. All rights reserved. Privacy, security, and usage policies